Muny’s Heart-Melting ‘Dear Evan Hansen’ Is Beacon of Light in Dark Times

Muny’s Heart-Melting ‘Dear Evan Hansen’ Is Beacon of Light in Dark Times

By Lynn Venhaus

Deeply personal and profoundly moving, “Dear Evan Hansen” grabs our hearts and doesn’t let go.

Sensitively presented by director Rob Ruggiero and perceptively told by an emotionally engaged cast in its powerful Muny and Midwest regional debut, the musical is anchored by an astounding Michael Fabisch, who immediately wins us over as the awkward outcast Evan.

In his star-making turn, the captivating Fabisch, who played Evan on the most recent national tour, projects vulnerability and a remarkable range of feelings as an anxious high school senior struggling to fit in.

He is in nearly every scene — his physical stamina as impressive as the emotional depth he expresses in the signature songs “You Will Be Found,” “For Forever,” “Words Fail,” and “Waving Through a Window.”

Through a series of unfortunate events, Evan finds himself entangled in a web of lies after a troubled classmate’s suicide, which spirals out of control.

Rob McClure (left) and Michael Fabisch in the Muny production of “Dear Evan Hansen.” Photo by The Muny | Emily Santel

When you first hear that everything is based on a lie, you may have a ‘wait – what?’ reaction. However, Evan’s hard-fought journey of self-discovery resonates. He makes mistakes, and there are consequences, but ultimately, there is hope.

The story asks us not to judge Evan but understand why he created this charade — to comfort a grieving family. Forgiveness is a powerful tool here too.

The spotlight on the anonymous and anti-social Connor Murphy has a beneficial outcome — The Connor Project, a viral movement for inclusion, that grew from the students’ efforts.

Statistics tell us loneliness is at an all-time high. A National 4-H Council survey found that seven out of 10 young people say they struggle with mental health issues. I think this musical can save lives, and if it helps someone reach out, what a wonderful result. It is certain to spark conversations.

From left: Michael Fabisch, Bryan Munar and Joshua Bess in the Muny production of “Dear Evan Hansen.” Photo by Phillip Hamer

Even during an intense summer heat wave, a highly attentive audience leaned in, rapt. Sensing that the musical connected to each person in some way, no matter what age, I was struck by the hush of the engaged crowd – except for a few overheard sniffles here and there (understandable, and with me, unavoidable).

Try getting through “So Big/So Small,” a heart-melting vocal by Jackie Burns, who plays Evan’s caring single mother Heidi.  Her husband left when Evan was 7 and has a whole new life in Colorado. She addresses her shortcomings in this tearjerker.

Burns, Broadway’s longest running Elphaba in “Wicked,” is raw and real in her portrayal of Evan’s hard-working, exhausted mom, juggling her job as a nurse’s aide, school classes to become a paralegal, and trying to provide for her son but not always being there for him.

“I knew there would be moments that I’d miss
And I knew there would be space I couldn’t fill
And I knew I’d come up short a million different ways
And I did
And I do
And I will”

Pass the tissues. Not only does this song foster empathy, but the entire show can be viewed as therapeutic/cathartic – and necessary. Oh, the dialogues to follow in homes across America.

Michael Fabisch and Jackie Burns in the Muny production of “Dear Evan Hansen.” Photo by The Muny | Emily Santel

The show is universally relatable because of its themes of mental health, grief, social anxiety, fear of being alone, yearning for acceptance, and understanding how others feel invisible or unvalidated for who they are.

While the high school setting conveys both despair and wanting to please in an overwhelming digital age, the adults are affected too, as they do ‘adulting’ in an ever-changing playing field where the goal posts keep moving.

Everybody seems to be trying to do the right thing and find their place in the world, flaws and all. That is why the cast’s ability to depict frustration, confusion and joy is felt, landing in every corner of the Forest Park seats. Who wouldn’t want an opportunity for reinvention?

An ensemble peppered with fresh faces and seasoned principal performers tugs hard at the heartstrings as their impassioned voices unite in splendid harmonies. The Act One closer, “You Will Be Found” is an anthem we always need, but more so in our contemporary cold, cruel world.

Standing out in supporting roles – and making their Muny debuts – are Joshua Bess as the anonymous and aggressive Connor, whose apathy may have masked a cry for help, Afra Sophia Tully as his sister Zoe, and Bryan Munar as tech whiz Jared, a family friend who reluctantly helps Evan become an internet sensation.

Savy Jackson in the Muny production of “Dear Evan Hansen.” Photo by Phillip Hamer

Savy Jackson, last year’s Ariel in “The Little Mermaid,” is charming as the cheerful over-achieving Alana. Rob McClure, in his ninth Muny show, and his real-life wife Maggie Lakis, also a Muny vet, portray Connor’s parents Larry and Cynthia, pain and sorrow etched on their faces.

Pairing with Fabisch, Bess is light-hearted in “Sincerely, Me,” Tully has a tender duet in “Only Us.” and McClure sentimental in “To Break in a Glove.”

A fusion of musical theatre and pop, the score by composer Benj Pasek and lyricist Justin Paul is well-integrated into the recognizable story by Steve Levenson.

Golden boys Pasek and Paul, the latest EGOT winners (20 and 21st), earned Tonys and a Grammy Award for “Dear Evan Hansen,” an Oscar for “City of Stars” from “LaLa Land,” and the primetime Emmy for the song “Which of the Pickwick Triplets Did It?”, from “Only Murders in the Building” in the episode “Sitzprobe.”

With its beautiful imagery of an idyllic day, indelible poetry about friendship, and haunting melody, “For Forever” hits hard. While it’s a total fabrication from Evan to soothe the Murphys in mourning, it emphasizes Evan’s aching desire for connection.

Michael Fabisch (center) and members of the company of the Muny production of “Dear Evan Hansen.” Photo by The Muny | Emily Santel

The Muny concept for this show works well – not overpowering with razzle-dazzle but letting the identifiable story with its unforgettable characters be the focus. Ruggiero, in directing his 11th show, has a knack for staging on the outdoor space, and his insight influences the production’s vibrant tempo.

A 17-member cast, with eight principal characters and including “virtual community voices”  – Kaley Bender, Vera Brown, Alex Daspit, Spencer Davis Milford, Zoe Brooke Reed, Essence Anisa Tyler, Noah Van Esse, and Oscar Williams, is expanded to include a 24-person teen ensemble on stage and eight vocalists offstage.

The projection technology, its depiction of social media, and setting the scene locations, helps illustrate the isolation – and the intimacy. Michael Schweikardt’s sleek scenic design, paired with Kevan Loney’s video design, is a terrific visual landscape.

Eschewing the need to open up scenes, Ruggiero has pared them down instead – dining room, bedrooms, school computer lab – with human interaction, strikingly illuminated by lighting designer Rob Denton.

John Shivers and David Patridge’s sound design was effective in its integration of electronic communication as well as delivering crisp vocals in musical numbers.

Michael Fabisch and Afra Sophia Tully in the Muny production of “Dear Evan Hansen.” Photo by Phillip Hamer

Music director Roberto Sinha strategically used sumptuous strings and mastered poignant orchestrations by Alex Lacamoire, while Justin Paul’s vocal arrangements added emotional heft. How can you not fall in love with that score?

Costume designer Joseph Shrope outfitted the characters in age-appropriate casual attire, and of course, Evan wore his trademark polo shirts.

The musical, which opened on Broadway in December 2016, won six of the nine Tony Awards it was nominated for in 2017, including Best Musical, Best Book of a Musical, Best Original Score, Best Actor in a Leading Role in a Musical (Ben Platt as Evan), Best Featured Actress in a Musical (Rachel Bay Jones as Heidi), and Best Orchestrations.

It ran on Broadway until Sept. 18, 2022, for nearly six years, including 1,672 regular performances and 21 previews.

Because of its enduring and extraordinary impact, the musical remains a timeless, moving experience. Emphasizing truth, the Muny’s adaptation is worthy of your time and attention – for it speaks from the heart straight to the heart. You are not alone.

The Muny presents “Dear Evan Hansen” July 28 – Aug. 3 on the Forest Park outdoor stage. For more information or tickets, visit www.muny.org.

The company of the Muny production of “Dear Evan Hansen.” Photo by Phillip Hamer

Muny’s Indelible ‘Come From Away’ Magnifies Kindness, Compassion

Muny’s Indelible ‘Come From Away’ Magnifies Kindness, Compassion

By Lynn Venhaus

“Come From Away” wraps you in a warm hug and doesn’t let go.

Brimming with heart, humor and humanity, the 2017 musical arrived for its highly anticipated Muny debut with all the feels intact, making clever use of the expansive stage and its dynamic ensemble demonstrating the extraordinary power of kindness during adversity.

This deeply personal, emotionally complex story has resonated strongly with theatregoers, and the Muny’s customary attention to casting and execution put that at the forefront. The first-rate cast projects enthusiasm and affection for this material from start to finish, buoyed by the creative team’s excellence and the audience’s embrace.

The 100-minute show focuses on the town of Gander, Newfoundland, and its hospitable response to 38 planes landing at their airport with 6,122 passengers and 473 crew on Sept. 11, 2001.

After the terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon, the FAA closed the US airspace and Operation Yellow Ribbon began – a coordinated effort to accommodate diverted flights. Gander was among the towns helping, including nearby Lewisporte and Appleton.

The company of the Muny production of “Come From Away.” Photo by Phillip Hamer

Gander, a Canadian community of about 9,600 and home to the Gander International Airport, opened their homes and converted schools and community buildings into shelters, becoming a beacon of light in the darkest of times.

In the U.S. and for those affected elsewhere, it was an anxious and uncertain period. The fearful passengers had to stay on planes for many hours, without any information other than it was an emergency, until they were officially released and herded into buses with only their carry-ons.

Based on these real people’s stories, the husband-and-wife team of Irene Sankoff and David Hein vividly wove acts of compassion, listening, laughing, hospitality and fellowship into a heart-tugging narrative to accompany their music and lyrics.

They also addressed challenges like culture clashes and language barriers, and how people worked through tense situations.

They focused on a rerouted American Airlines flight from Paris headed to Dallas. Because of Gander’s generosity to strangers who couldn’t leave for five days, lasting friendships formed, resulting in a 10-year reunion in 2011, where the writers interviewed those in attendance.

Heidi Blickenstaff in the Muny production of “Come From Away.” Photo by Phillip Hamer

“Come from Away” truly is a remarkable story, with distinct characters that touch our soul. Thus, a theatrical gem was born with tender loving care – now the longest running musical ever from Canada. The Broadway run, interrupted by COVID, played to sold-out houses for 1,670 regular performances and 25 previews from February 2017 to October 2022.

Nominated for seven Tony Awards, including Best Musical, Christopher Ashley won for directing. (“Dear Evan Hansen” was the big winner that night and will debut at the Muny in July).

A trio from last year’s revered classic “Les Miserables” has returned to craft another powerful tale of enduring connection – director Seth Sklar-Heyn, choreographer Jesse Robb (whose mother was born and raised in Newfoundland), and costume designer Gail Baldoni.

Their meticulous work, along with exemplary essentials from scenic designer Edward E. Haynes Jr., video designer Mike Tutaj, lighting designer Rob Denton, and wig designer Kelley Jordan, created a vibrant tableau that immediately drew the large Muny crowd into the Far North.

Haynes’ ingenious stairs-jet configuration rotated, using the turntable to swiftly create the necessary spaces. Tutaj’s video work uses news footage from Rogers TV and suggests locations like Tim Horton’s and Trailway Pub, to add awareness of time and place. And Denton’s superb lighting gave the show its usual intimate feel.

Alan H. Green in the Muny production of “Come From Away.” Photo by Phillip Hamer

As they seamlessly portray multiple roles – both townsfolks and ‘plane people,’ the players talk directly to us. The proud islanders start their routine on a Tuesday morning, introducing themselves in a chill-inducing “Welcome to the Rock.”

“You are here at the start of a moment…”

Our reaction is immediate, taking us right back to that frightening morning – when we heard, what we saw, how we felt – if you experienced it. If not, its tone is evocative of that tragic day and the aftermath.

Muny stalwart Adam Heller is well-suited to play the take-charge mayor, Claude Elliott, among other characters, leading the opening number and the raucous “Screech In” (involving kissing a codfish and downing rum shots).

Looking back, he tells the audience: “Tonight we honor what was lost, but we also commemorate what we found.”

Abigail Isom and Adam Heller in the Muny production of “Come From Away.” Photo by Phillip Hamer

With her powerhouse mezzo-soprano, Heidi Blickenstaff soars as the trailblazing pilot Beverley Bass in the signature song “Me and the Sky.” Impressive as mom Mary Jane in the national tour of “Jagged Little Pill” (including the Fox in January 2024), she is captivating as Beverley, whose passion for aviation drove her career but she now worries that her workspace has become a weapon.

The dozen performers, appearing like regular folk, clearly delineate multiple characters, whether through accents, wardrobe pieces or personality shifts.

Memorable “come from aways” include two-time Grammy winner Tamika Lawrence as Hannah O’Rourke, who is frantically trying to reach her son, a New York firefighter. Her solo, “I Am Here” is heart-breaking.

Stellar veteran performers John Bolton and Ashley Brown are a delightful duo as the British bachelor Nick Marson and divorced mom Diane Gray, whose budding friendship might be more.

A gay couple, “the two Kevins” – Jason Tam as Kevin Tuerff and Trey DeLuna as Kevin Jung, who seemed to be at odds, disagree often. One’s all in for being a good sport, and the other is not comfortable in the public situation.

Trey DeLuna and the company of the Muny production of “Come From Away.” Photo by The Muny | Emily Santel

DeLuna, who was in the national tour, delivers a gut-wrenching turn as Egyptian chef Ali, who is under suspicion as a Muslim, and prejudice grows.

One of the most moving numbers is “Prayer,” showing travelers practicing their faith – Jews, Christians, Catholics and Muslims.

Alan H. Green is comical as Bob, who is confused by all the nice emanating from the locals. He also plays a pilot and an African traveler who can’t speak English. If he looks familiar, in St. Louis, he starred in “Sister Act” at the Muny and in “The Karate Kid” at Stages.

On the home front, total pro Zoe Vonder Haar is ideal as good-natured Beulah Davis, one of the major caregivers. And she doubles as a nervous flyer who gets tipsy and loudly sings “My Heart Will Go On” from “Titanic,” which they watched as an in-flight movie.

Likable Jacob Keith Watson smoothly transforms into the police constable Oz Fudge, a bar owner, Jewish rabbi, a surly traveler and others.

From left: Zoe Vonder Haar, Jacob Keith Watson and Jason Tam in the Muny production of “Come From Away.” Photo by Phillip Hamer

Seasoned Muny vet Abigail Isom is the amiable TV news reporter Janice, whose first day on the job is 9-11, and easily transitions to a freaking out flight attendant. She also plays a store clerk, getting laughs with: “Thank you for coming to Walmart. Would you like to come back to my house for a shower?”

Andrea Burns is the pragmatic SPCA representative, taking care of 19 animals in cargo cages, including endangered Bonobo chimpanzees that are headed to the Columbus Zoo in Ohio.

Dialect coach Joanna Battles helped the cast become Canadians with a specific accent, and their work was impeccable.

The teen ensemble acting as townsfolk and travelers include Chloe Jennings, Grant LaMartina, Annakait Peters-Bahkou, Drew Mathers, Jarod Rhodes, Jameson Roam and Will Schulte.

Standby for the women is Leah Berry and for the men, Spencer Davis Milford.

From left: Ashley Brown, Zoe Vonder Haar, John Bolton and Adam Heller in the Muny production of “Come From Away.” Photo by The Muny | Emily Santel

The vocally strong cast harmoniously blends together in the songs that are an integral part of the storytelling – “38 Planes,” “Blankets and Bedding,” “28 Hours/Wherever We Are,” “Darkness and Trees,” “On the Edge,” “Stop the World,” “Somewhere in the Middle of Nowhere,” and “Something’s Missing” – expressing the necessary emotions.

The unifying score reflects the cultural heritage of Newfoundland – using Celtic rhythms and traditional folk, and fuses neatly with emotive modern musical theatre elements.

The robust orchestrations are by Aaron Eriksmoen, with arrangements by Ian Eisendrath, incorporating a fiddle and even an “ugly stick” (household items) on stage.

The Muny orchestra, energetically led by music director Evan Roider, captures the score’s unique sound, adding a harp and whistles to its instruments.

The first national tour came to the Fox Theatre in May 2019, and a return weekend engagement followed in 2023, striking a chord (blubbered throughout, and I wasn’t alone).

With multiple cameras, Apple TV+ filmed the Broadway cast in front of a live audience, including some 9-11 survivors and frontline workers, on Sept. 11, 2021, commemorating the 20th anniversary. It has been available for streaming since Sept. 10, 2022.

Tamika Lawrence in the Muny production of “Come From Away.” Photo by The Muny | Emily Santel

While 9-11 was 24 years ago, that time is etched into our collective memories. After a touching brief display of unity and flag-waving, today’s America is very different.

We now have a divisive political climate that’s mean-spirited and worrisome. Then we were isolated during a global pandemic that impacted our lives, an ever-mutating virus that killed more than 7 million people. More short fuses, more fear of others, anger and outrage are prevailing attitudes.

Recently, in St Louis, the deadliest tornado since 1959 tore apart neighborhoods. Watching a community come together on the Muny stage recalled empathetic responses of the past six weeks here, for people stepped up when called upon to do so.

We’ve been through a lot – as a country and as a region. Yet, glimmers of hope emerge, along with everyday heroes, and it’s gratifying to feel the uplift that “Come from Away” provides.

Mission accomplished. Triumphing with its affecting production that appreciative audiences won’t soon forget, the Muny reminds us why our shared experience is what live theater does best.

The Muny presents “Come from Away” nightly at 8:15 p.m. from June 26 to July 2 at the outdoor theatre in Forest Park. The production is 1 hour, 40 minutes without intermission. For more information, or for tickets, visit www.muny.org

The company of the Muny production of “Come From Away.” Photo by Phillip Hamer
The company of the Muny production of “Come From Away.” Photo by Phillip Hamer

Take Ten with Spencer Davis Milford

Take Ten with Spencer Davis Milford

By Lynn Venhaus

Whether he stands out in a challenging role or disappears into a classic character, Spencer Davis Milford is a familiar presence, having matured on local stages and now recognized nationally.

Fresh from the U.S. and New Zealand premieres of the epic fantasy tale “The Lord of the Rings” musical adaptation as hero Frodo Baggins, the St. Louis native has returned to tackle one of his “dream roles,” as the cunning Master of Ceremonies in New Jewish Theatre’s powerful interpretation of “Cabaret.”

“Getting the chance to tell this story with the passion and creative leadership that Rebekah Scallet, Ellen Isom, and Carter Haney are bringing is incredibly special. I’m grateful that they asked me to be a part of this amazing cast,” he said. “This had always been one of my dream roles when I was younger and became obsessed with musical theater, and I always was on the lookout for an opportunity and I couldn’t pass it up.”

Performances have been selling out (including this upcoming weekend), they’ve extended the run through April 13 for four more performances, and he’s been garnering rave reviews for his magnetic performance as the menacing Emcee with the salacious grin. It’s a departure from anything he’s done before.

“Cabaret.” Photo by Jon Gitchoff.

Director Rebekah Scallet, whom Milford said had a clear vision, was impressed with her cast’s work ethic.

“The entire ensemble of Cabaret, from top to bottom, was a dream to work with. Everyone was incredibly committed to this production and worked their tails off – this was no easy feat, given our short rehearsal schedule and small ensemble (we only had 11 and typically the show is done with more like 18), but this group was up for any challenge. We began the process with a tour of the St. Louis Kaplan Feldman Museum, and I think that really cemented for everyone the important reasons for doing this show now at NJT. I am so grateful for all of their talents and their passion,” she said.

New Jewish Theatre’s production takes on an even greater relevance as rates of anti-Semitism in the United States are reaching all-time highs. The musical illustrates how the Nazis rose to power while the German citizens either ignored what was happening, refused to believe fascism possibly could happen, or chose to go along with it to ensure their own survival.

Milford, as Frodo Baggins, in the touring “The Lord of the Rings” musical. Photo provided.

“The themes of the show are just as prevalent in our society today as they were when the show was written, unfortunately,” he said.

The Wool Studio’s intimate and immersive setting brings the audience right into the Kit Kat Club as they enter the world of 1929 Germany.

Scallet described Milford as a ‘dream to work with’ on “Cabaret.”

“Not only is he a super talented actor, singer, and dancer, he is a thoughtful and sensitive human. The emcee is a challenging character to wrap your head around, both who he is and how he functions in the play, and Spencer and I had wonderful conversations, diving deep to discover his journey. And I absolutely love what he found,” she said.

A veteran of the Muny, Stages St. Louis and the Repertory Theatre of St. Louis, Milford spread his wings on the first national tours of “Billy Elliot” (as the “Tall Boy” and understudy to Michael) and “How the Grinch Stole Christmas.” (as Boo Hoo).

In 2013, he appeared on Broadway in the revival of the 1947 Terrance Rattigan play “The Winslow Boy” as the titular character, Ronnie. The drama, about a family’s fight to clear their son’s name after an unjust expulsion from naval college, is based on a real incident, and starred Tony winner Roger Rees and Oscar nominee Mary Elizabeth Mastrantonio as his parents.

Acting since he was a youngster, he played Michael Darling in The Muny’s “Peter Pan,” Winthrop in “The Music Man” at Stages St. Louis, Rudy in “Over the Tavern” and :”A Boy” (aka Peter) in “Peter and the Starcatcher,” both at The Rep.

 Among his recent roles at the Muny, he was Gene Vincent, Dick Clark and part of the ensemble in 2023’s “Beautiful: the Carole King Musical,” Davey in 2017’s “Newsies,” the ensemble in 2016’s “42nd Street” and in the ensemble in 2022’s “Camelot.” He said performing at the Muny in the summer is one of his most favorite things to do in St. Louis.

Spencer Davis Milford, as Davey, Tessa Grady as Katherine, and Gabriel Cytron as Les dance rehearsal for The Muny’s Newsies in 2017. St Louis Post-Dispatch photo.

Michael Baxter, The Muny’s associate artistic director, has worked with Spencer for many years. first as a Muny Teen. Baxter, part of the Muny artistic team since 2012, spearheaded the teen program, revamping it and being director/choreographer, serving eight seasons. He became the resident choreographer in 2015 and promoted to his current position in 2018.

When asked for a comment, he said: “Spencer is an incredible talent, a true ‘song and dance’ man who comes alive in every role. He is valuable in an ensemble because he honors his essence but is a proper actor who is great with language. He lives in the ‘truth’ of the play and activates every role/line with specificity, rhythm and nuance. I trust him implicitly and he always delivers exceptional work.”

In my Aug. 11, 2017 review of “Newsies” for the Belleville News-Democrat, I wrote: “Other standouts include appealing Spencer Davis Milford as the smart go-getter Davey who handles setbacks with great aplomb, scene-stealing rookie sensation Gabriel Cytron as his adorable waif brother Les,,,.”

Photo below is from “Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf?” at the Fulton Theatre in 2023, with Spencer as Nick.

He has performed at professional regional theatres, including in Chicago, as Barnaby in “Hello, Dolly!” in 2022, as Rusty Charlie in “Guys and Dolls” in 2024, and as Tony in “Billy Elliot: The Musical” a year ago.

The Chicago Shakespeare Theatre opened “The Lord of the Rings” musical last July before its New Zealand premiere in November 2024. The musical, originally written in 2006, is based on J.R.R. Tolkien’s 1954 novel about a humble hobbit who is asked to play the hero and undertake a treacherous mission to destroy an evil, magical ring. It’s set in the world of Middle-earth. The music is by A.R. Rahman, Vartina and Christopher Nightingale, with the lyrics and book by Shaun McKenna and Matthew Warchus.

The reviews described it as a visual marvel, ambitious and featuring a hard-working cast. “This Lord of the Rings is a memorable piece of work. It is undeniably intense, exciting, and powerful,” wrote Chicago on Stage..

Varsha Anjali, a critic for The New Zealand Herald, said “The cast kicked ass,” describing Milford as “charming.” and the musical as “exhilarating.”

While he is in town, we asked him to answer our Take Ten questionnaire, and we interviewed him on the March 12 PopLifeSTL Presents podcast.

Here are his responses:

Take Ten with Spencer Davis Milford

1. What is special about your latest project?

“Cabaret” is widely considered one of the best musicals of all time. The themes of the show are just as prevalent in our society today as they were when the show was written, unfortunately.”

“Getting the chance to tell this story with the passion and creative leadership that Rebekah Scallet, Ellen Isom, and Carter Haney are bringing is incredibly special. I’m grateful that they asked me to be a part of this amazing cast.”

2. Why did you choose your profession/pursue the arts?

“The first time I was onstage in a musical was at five years old in ‘Little Shop of Horrors’ at Shrewsbury Youth Theater and I’ve been obsessed with performing ever since. I knew very early on that I wanted to be a professional actor.”

3. How would your friends describe you?

“My friends would describe me as mostly laid back and fun, but when I’m passionate about something I am very committed and a little intense.”

4. How do you like to spend your spare time?

“I’m a pretty competitive person and I love sports, so I play a lot of golf and disc golf.”

5. What is your current obsession?

“The green liquidIV packets, electrolytes AND caffeine? Sign me up.”

6. What would people be surprised to find out about you?

“I think Farotto’s has the best t-ravs (toasted ravioli) in STL. Maybe that’s not a surprise.”

With Molly Hogg in “Peter and the Starcatcher” at The Rep in 2015.

7. Can you share one of your most defining moments in life?

“Playing Frodo in the US premiere of ‘The Lord of the Rings’ musical and also doing the show in New Zealand. It was the most challenging and rewarding experience of my life.”

8. Who do you admire most?

“My parents. They’re the hardest working people I know and they’re incredibly supportive of me and my three siblings. I don’t know where I’d be without them.”

9. What is at the top of your bucket list?

“Being in a show that tours all over Europe.”

10. What is your favorite thing to do in St. Louis?

“Performing at The Muny. Going to a Blues playoff game. Eating Imo’s pizza and t-ravs is pretty sweet too. I can’t pick a favorite.”

11. What’s next?

“Nothing I can announce yet but it’s going to be an exciting summer for sure!”


More About Spencer Davis Milford

Birthplace: St. Louis
Education: Masters in Acting from the Royal Conservatoire of Scotland
Favorite jobs/roles/plays or work in your medium? Lord of the Rings, Buzz directed by Carrie Preston, Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf, Billy Elliot
Dream job/opportunity: “Hamlet”

Photo at left is curtain call from “The Winslow Boy” on Broadway.

Milford, Jay Armstrong Johnson, Gabriel Cytron and Tessa Grady in the Muny’s “Newsies.” Photo by Phillip Hamer.

New Jewish Theatre’s Hard-Hitting, Heart-Wrenching ‘Cabaret’ More Relevant Than Ever

New Jewish Theatre’s Hard-Hitting, Heart-Wrenching ‘Cabaret’ More Relevant Than Ever

By Lynn Venhaus

“There was a cabaret, and there was a master of ceremonies, and there was a city called Berlin, in a country called Germany… and it was the end of the world” – “Cabaret” 1966

Eerily relevant now more than ever, the musical “Cabaret” has only grown in potency and insight over its 59-year history.

In New Jewish Theatre’s haunting production, director Rebekah Scallet has faithfully adapted Sam Mendes’ brilliant 1998 revival that emphasized the sinister motives as we witness the gathering storm that would lead to World War II and the Holocaust.

However, she has focused on making sure the parallels between then and now are clear, and she has strengthened the shattering epilogue even more than Mendes did. She puts a hard-hitting NJT stamp on it.

As impressive as her track record has been since becoming the artistic director in 2022, it’s noteworthy to mention that this is the first musical she has directed in Wool Studio.

Through the decadent setting of the seedy Kit Kat Club in 1929 Berlin, we witness the end of the Weimar Republic and the rise of the Nazis.

Photo by Jon Gitchoff.

This passionate cast resonates because of how committed they are to the bleak and shocking themes. In their telling of this story, the desperation is palpable. And their layered approach to the hummable John Kander-Fred Ebb score is commendable.

As the cunning Emcee welcomes patrons in “Wilkommen,” he seductively entices: “Leave your troubles outside! So—life is disappointing? Forget it! In here, life is beautiful. The girls are beautiful. Even the orchestra is beautiful!”

In a magnetic performance, Spencer Davis Milford embraces the tawdriness and makes sure the ominous feeling grows. He lurks in other scenes where he’s not the saucy showman, his menacing presence foreshadowing the horrors that are ahead.

Oh, he has doused his “I Don’t Care Much” and “If You Could See Her” in irony, making those numbers even more chilling. After such iconic actors as Joel Grey, Alan Cumming and Eddie Redmayne have created their indelible portraits, Milford makes the role his own.

Fresh from his starring role as Frodo Baggins in “The Lord of the Rings” national tour, he’s back home making his mark in yet another special show. His work has always captivated since he was a youngster, whether on stage at The Muny or The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis, or a myriad of other companies. But this is quite a departure from anything he’s done.

When it was time for “Tomorrow Belongs to Me,” I braced myself, for its intensity remains affecting — and induces chills.

As conditions deteriorate in the polarizing landscape, those loyal to the “new Germany” face apathetic citizens and those who don’t understand the consequences.. In hindsight, how could they and why were people so unaware?

Soencer Davis Milford as the Master of Ceremonies. Photo by Jon Gitchoff.

The innovative 1998 Tony winning Mendes collaboration with Rob Marshall deconstructed the heralded 1966 Hal Prince show in an earlier 1993 London re-imagining. While the original introduced social commentary in uncommon staging, this version heightens the present danger of ignoring anti-Semitism.

Mendes and Marshall would go on to helm Oscar-winning films in the early 2000s – “American Beauty” and “Chicago” respectively – but their impact has carried over for several vivid revivals in the past 27 years, notably 2014 and 2024, and in this striking, moving interpretation.

Scallet makes the most of the Wool Studio’s intimate setting, through an immersive experience placing some audience members in club configurations.

As the small but vibrant ensemble delivers high-energy precision in musical numbers, Scallet skillfully maintains fluidity throughout, with brisk staging, as one scene quickly melds into another.

Ellen Isom’s crisp and snappy choreography adds pizzazz to “Don’t Tell Mama,” “Mein Herr,” “Money,” and “Two Ladies,” and the robust kick line number in second act is an exceptional feat.

Otto Klemp, Hailey Medrano and Jayson Heil. Photo by Jon Gitchoff.

Music Director Carter Haney conducts the band on stage – Brad Martin on drums, Alerica Anderson on a stand-up bass, and Kris Pineda on accordion and trombone, and their polished presentation is a highlight.

Scenic Designer David Blake’s visually interesting set has a grand balcony implying secretive dalliances behind closed doors while the downstairs doubles as the nightclub stage and both Sally’s and Fraulein Schneider’s shabby living quarters.

Denisse Chavez’s lighting design shrewdly draws us into the action, highlighting the moods, while Justin Smith’s sound design captures the atmosphere.

Hailey Medrano and Dustin Lane Petrillo are strong together as flighty, flirty nightclub singer Sally Bowles and broke American writer Clifford Bradshaw, brought together by fate, desire and living on the edge.

Separately, they are heart-tugging. Petrillo brings a discernable gravitas to every role he tackles, including virtuoso work in “Red,” The Immigrant,” “Hamlet” and “A Long Day’s Journey into Night” on local stages during the past two years.

Not as innocent as he first appears, and initially caught up in the whirlwind, Cliff eventually becomes the keen —-and appalled — observer whose conscience can no longer ignore the signs.

Dustin Petrillo, Medrano and Milford. Photo by Jon Gitchoff.

His character is the fictionalized British writer Christopher Isherwood, who would go on to write the semi-autobiographical novel “Goodbye to Berlin.” The musical’s book by Joe Masteroff is based on the 1951 John Van Druten play “I Am a Camera,” which is adapted from Isherwood’s collection of short stories that he wrote between 1930 and 1933, published in 1939.

Medrano, who has returned to St. Louis with memorable turns in NJT’s “We All Fall Down” last year and work with Metro Theater Company, is at her most heart-wrenching when she refuses to leave her reckless livelihood for the safety and promise of a new life.

She makes drastic self-destructive decisions after spending much of the show flaunting her tough exterior that masks an emotional fragility.

In a smart change of pace, Medrano slows down several classic renditions, boosting their power – the raw, emotional “Maybe This Time” and the title song, aka “Life is a Cabaret” (old chum!) – infused with regret – are both knockouts.

The undercurrent of irony laced with a stinging gut-punch, her anguish seeping through as she breaks. It’s all the more tragic that she chooses to remain oblivious to what’s happening.

Medrano as Sally Bowles. Photo by Jon Gitchoff.

Because Sally is such a confused mess, she is not always sympathetic, but Medrano is alluring when she’s “always on” as Sally Bowles, and tender, for a time, with new love interest Cliff.

In the show’s most devastating performance, Jane Paradise projects world-weariness but also a yearning she hides with pragmatism. The veteran character actress is known for lived-in portrayals and is often the MVP in any ensemble.

As Fraulein Schneider who discovers late-in-life love, her doomed romance with shy, kind fruit vendor Herr Schultz, played sweetly by Dave Cooperstein, is agonizing, for he is a Jew, and their shared dreams collapse under the weight of current events.

From their joyous duets “The Pineapple Song” and “Married,” to her melancholy “So What” and the tragic “What Would You Do?” are sad reminders of the choices we make and life’s turns, depriving them of even a shred of happiness.

Also standing out is Aaron Fischer as the calculating smuggler Ernst Ludwig, whose growing fervor for the Third Reich is alarming. With an impeccable German accent, Fischer slowly reveals his bigotry. Fischer, fairly new to the professional stage, and splendid in last fall’s “Anastasia: The Musical” at Tesseract Theatre Company, is one of the most exciting performers to keep your eye on.

Aaron Fischer and Petrillo. Photo by Jon Gitchoff.

In fact, John Wilson’s dialect work is superb from all 11 performers. Besides doubling as soldiers and shady characters, the ensemble includes devil-may-care revelers celebrating their hedonistic culture before fear and chaos will grip their world. The nightclub’s naughty boys and girls, and their free-spirited customers live in the moment: Otto Klemp as Bobby, officer, ensemble and on clarinet; Jayson Heil as Victor, Max, ensemble and on violin; Amarachi Kalu as Lulu and on the flute; Caroline Pillow as Fritzie; and Lillian Cooper as Texas and the gorilla.

Costume Designer Michele Friedman Siler expertly incorporated luxurious shiny blacks and reds for the performers, often with torn fishnet stockings, and more middle-class attire for everyone else. Because of doubling characters, costume changes are remarkably smooth.

We won’t forget, we can’t forget the unflinching cautionary tale this enduring musical tells us.

Jane Paradise and Dave Cooperstein. Photo by Jon Gitchoff.

The New Jewish Theatre presents “Cabaret” from March 20 to April 13. Please check for showtimes, as several Wednesday shows have been added as well as an extended run. For mature audiences, the show has adult content. The show runs 2 hours and 15 minutes, with a 15-minute intermission. Performances take place at the SFC Performing Arts Center, 2 Millstone Campus Drive. For more information: jccstl.com. Tickets are available online at newjewishtheatre.org or by phone at 314.442.3283.

NJT’s 2025 Season is generously sponsored by Mary Strauss, with Cabaret receiving additional sponsorship from Stellie Siteman and the Siteman Family Foundation.

Alongside the production, NJT hosts special events that will give the audience a special understanding of the iconic musical:

Saturday, April 5 –The Weimar Republic the Rise of Hitler with Helen Turner

Have a conversation with Helen Turner, Education Director for the St. Louis Kaplan Feldman Holocaust Museum, as she presents information about the Weimar Republic and the real-life historical events that provide the backdrop for Cabaret. This event will take place between the matinee and evening performances on Saturday, April 5. Doors will open at 4:30 with the presentation beginning at 5pm. Light refreshments will be provided. The presentation is free, but reservations are required at https://formstack.io/80312

Photo by Jon Gitchoff.